Ecotricity logotype
/Our news/2018/Ecotricity propose Swansea Bay alternatives

Our news

    Browse archives
    Our news

    English & Scottish tidal lagoon schemes emerge on morning of Swansea Bay review

    Press enquiries

    If you are a journalist with a media enquiry, please contact our Press Office by email at

    For all other general enquiries, please call 01453 756 111 or email

    By Max Boon
    9 May 2018
    English & Scottish tidal lagoon schemes emerge on morning of Swansea Bay review - Image 3

    Ecotricity has today presented the government with two alternative tidal lagoon proposals, ahead of a joint select committee review of the Swansea Bay tidal lagoon project and the government decision making process behind what some describe as a delay. 

    MPs on the business and Welsh affairs committee will begin taking evidence on Wednesday morning from a range of participants, including ministers, Charles Hendry (author of the Hendry report) and Mark Shorrock, chief executive of Tidal Lagoon Power, the company behind the Swansea project.

    The government has clearly indicated it felt unable to support the Swansea project to date, due to its excessive cost. 

    The two new plans unveiled today are in the Solway Firth, one on the English side of the border and the other on the Scottish side. Both projects would generate as much electricity as the Swansea Bay proposal, but at half the cost to build. That means they can make electricity for half the cost.

    The superior economics of these proposals are delivered by siting the lagoons offshore instead of onshore. Offshore tidal lagoons cost less to build, operate more efficiently and have significantly less environmental impact.

    Ecotricity shared this information with former energy minister Charles Hendry as he drafted his independent review of tidal lagoons, nearly two years ago, but the concept of offshore and its inherent advantages had no mention in the final report. Hendry instead focused on the need to move swiftly to support the Swansea scheme despite its incredible asking price.

    Ecotricity have partnered with Tidal Electric – the originators of the tidal lagoon concept, to develop the Solway sites; and are today signaling to the government that they are ready to take part in a competitive process, to ensure value for public money. 

    Dale Vince, founder of Ecotricity, said: “The government has done well to resist the last couple of years of intense lobbying pressure from backers of the Swansea scheme, there was never a case for paying that much or for moving too quickly to allow for proper competition.

    "In the last year the asking price for the Swansea project appears to have dropped considerably (by up to half), that’s a valuable use of time by the government. But there’s more to go. 

    "The reasons cited by Hendry to move quickly to support this expensive first tidal lagoon project (Swansea) have all fallen away. The case for an open competitive process, to kick start this nascent industry and ensure value for public money, remains compelling.  

    "Offshore wind is a great example of the process, it has been a tremendous success for the government. Starting out at almost twice the price of onshore wind it has fallen in price by 50% in the last three years. This same competitive process could be used to bring new tidal projects forward.

    "The projects we have unveiled today are ready to take part in a proper process. There is no need to rush; done properly tidal lagoons could play a big part in our future energy mix, and in lowering our energy bills. There are other companies and other projects that would take part in a proper process.”

    For more information about Offshore vs Onshore lagoons – visit –

    Similar articles

    allplants join the plant-powered revolution – and they have a treat for new Ecotricity customers!

    This month, we’re proud to partner with allplants, the pioneers behind ready meals with a difference. Not only are we partnered with them, but we’re also powering their kitchen!

    Manifesto book with long shadow

    Get the book!

    Manifesto out now

    Dale Vince portrait with bandana

    Our founder Dale Vince shares his thoughts on the green revolution

    Explore the site

    Don’t just take our word for it…

    Ecotricity is recommended by
    Ethical Consumer Best Buy logo
    • Our story
    • Our mission
    • Our manifesto
    • 28 years of Ecotricity
    • Ecotricity innovation
    • Walking the talk
    • Our partners
    • Our news
    • Your green energy
    • Ecotalk
    • Solar power export
    • Smart meters
    • Britwind
    • Carbon Footprint Calculator
    Ecotricity logotype

    Climate Clock

    The Climate Clock is a version of the Doomsday clock that has been running since 1947 - this tracks the risk of global man-made disaster, through man made technology (like nuclear weapons) - displaying the minutes and seconds left before midnight, when disaster strikes. The climate crisis is a small part of the calculations made.
    The climate clock uses a similar approach, but, focuses only on the climate crisis - which is the biggest and most urgent existential threat we face.
    "The Climate Clock is a countdown to the biggest man-made disaster we face - but also a measure by which we can track our progress - moving from fossil to renewable energy. It shows we have no time to lose - the clock is ticking…" Dale Vince, OBE.